2024 Board Composition

Title Name Audit Committee Remuneration Committee Nomination Committee Sustainability and Risk Management Committee
Chairman
Pan, Yung-Chung
V (Convener)
V (Convener)
Director
Pan, Yung-Tai
 V
Director
Duh, Jia-Bin
   
Director
Lee, Ji-Ren
Representative of 
Green Land Investment
Limited
V  
Independent Director
Wu, Chun-Pang
V (Convener)
V V  V
Independent Director
Wang, Jia-Chyi
 V V   V
Independent Director
Ma, Hui-Fan
 V
  V (Convener)
 V  
Independent Director
Huang, Shiou-Chuan 
V      
Independent Director
 Lai, Fei-Pei
       

 

 


Audit Committee Roles

The Audit Committee primarily assists the Board of Directors in fulfilling its supervisory responsibilities and is responsible for tasks assigned by company law, Securities and Exchange Act, and other relevant regulations. The Audit Committee of the Company is composed of all independent directors and operates in accordance with the Company's Audit Committee Charter, maintaining effective communication and contact channels with internal auditors, certified public accountants, and others within the company.

● For detailed organizational regulations and attendance at meetings, please refer to the Audit Committee Charter and the MOPS website


Remuneration Committee Roles

1. Set and regularly review the policy, system, standard and structure of remuneration for directors (including the Chairman), and managerial officers above the grade of President and Vice President based on the Company's goals, business performance, competitive environment and other factors.
2. Evaluate the outcomes of performance targets set for directors, the Chairman, and managerial officers above the grade of President and Vice President on a regular basis, then set the content and amount of individual remuneration based on individual performance evaluations. The content and amount of directors' remuneration should be reasonable and linked to the BOD performance.
3. Assess and determine the level of benefits for managerial officers above the grade of President and Vice President.

● For detailed organizational regulations and attendance at meetings, please refer to the Remuneration Committee Charter and the MOPS website 

 


Nomination Committee Roles

1. The identification of suitable candidates for recommendation to the BOD for appointment as Primax directors, President, CEO, CFO, and directors and supervisors at key subsidiaries.
2. A review of the qualifications of nominated candidates and advice to the BOD about any replacements that should be made.
● Details on the committee charter and meeting attendance can be found in the Nomination Committee Charter and MOPS website.
 

Sustainability and Risk Management Committee Roles

1. Examine various types of risk management policies.
2. Assess the adequacy of the risk management framework.
3. Review early warning and response measures for significant risk management issues and supervise improvement mechanisms.
4. Regularly report the implementation status of risk management to the board
● Details on the committee charter and meeting attendance can be found in the Risk Management Committee Charter and MOPS website.

 

Method of Directors Election

According to the Articles of Incorporation, directors (including independent directors) shall be elected according to the Candidate Nomination System. The professional qualifications and concurrent positions held, method of nomination and election, and other matters concerning independent directors shall be in compliance with applicable laws and regulations of the ROC Company Act and Securities and Exchange Act.

Diversification of The Board members

Board members at Primax Electronics are chosen through nomination and elected by all shareholders in a transparent, electronic voting session. All members possess the necessary abilities, knowledge, and experience to exercise their powers and responsibilities. All directors consider the long-term interests of the  Company' and shareholders' to be their top priority, and formulate their strategies in an objective manner. The Primax Board is convened at least once a quarter. In 2024, eight board meetings have been held as of August and the average attendance rate for all directors was 100%.

Board diversity is important to Primax and phased targets have been set: The number of women or foreigners sitting on the Board must exceed 10% by 2021 (completed), exceed 20% between 2024 and 2027(completed), and exceed 30% between 2030 and 2033.

Nine people sat on the Primax Board in 2024 including five independent directors (56%). Three of the independent directors have been in the position for fewer than 3 years,  one independent director has been in position for 3 to 6 years and one independent director has been in the position for 3 to 9 years. There were seven male directors (78%) and two female directors (22%) on the board. Two directors were aged between 71 and 80 years of age (22%), six were aged between 61 to 70 years of age (67%), and one was aged between 51 and 60 years of age (11%). Board directors, therefore, come fro from different age groups and generational change is gradually taking place.

In terms of the professional backgrounds of the directors: nine had experience in the industry and management (100%), four had experience in R&D (44%), six had backgrounds in marketing (67%), and two had financial experience (22%). In terms of the professional knowledge and skills required for directors, nine possessed the necessary knowledge and skills for leadership, decision-making, operations, and management (100%); seven of them had knowledge and skills of risk management (78%); five had an IT background (56%); five had financial and accounting backgrounds (56%), and one had legal knowledge and skills (11%).

Category  Name  Basic Composition    Professional Experience      Professional Knowledge and Skills       
Gender Nationality Age   Length of Service as Independent Director   Industry  R&D  MKT. Finance  Mgmt.  Leadership and Decision-making Biz. Mgmt. Risk Mgmt. IT F & A  Legal Affairs
Director  Pan, Yung-Chung Male Republic of China   61~70
ü ü ü   ü ü ü ü ü  
 Director Duh, Jia-Bin Male Republic of China ü   ü   ü ü ü ü ü ü  
Director  Lee, Ji-Ren
(Representative of Green Land Investment Limited)
Male Republic of China
ü   ü   ü ü ü ü   ü  
Director  Pan, Yung-Tai Male Republic of China  71~80  ü  ü     ü ü ü   ü    
Independent Director  Huang, Shiou-Chuan Male Republic of China Less than 3 years ü ü ü   ü ü ü ü ü ü
Independent Director  Lai, Fei-Pei Male Republic of China 61~70 ü ü ü   ü ü   ü ü    
Independent Director  Wu, Chun-Pang Male Republic of China 6 to 9 years     ü ü ü ü ü ü   ü ü
Independent Director  Ma, Hui-Fan Female Republic of China Less than 3 years ü       ü ü ü        
Independent Director  Wang, Jia-Chyi Female Republic of China 51~60 3 to 6 years ü ü ü ü ü   ü

Board of Directors' independence

Qualifi cation

Meet one of the following professional qualifications,
with at least five years of work experience
Independence Status (Note) Number Number of other public companies where the individual concurrently serves as an independent director
name Currently serving as an
instructor or higher post in a private or public college or university in the field of business, law, finance, accounting, or the business sector of the company
Currently serving as a Currently serving as ajudge, prosecutor, lawyer, accountant, or other professional practice or technician that must undergo national examinations and specialized license Work experience necessary for business administration, legalaffairs, finance, accounting, or business sector of the company 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Pan, Yung-Chung     ü         ü ü ü ü ü   ü ü 0
Pan, Yung-Tai     ü         ü ü ü ü ü   ü ü 0
Duh, Jia-Bin      ü     ü   ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü 0
Lee, Ji-Ren ü     ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü 1
Wu, Chun-Pang     ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü 0
Wang, Jia-Chyi     ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü 0
Ma, Hui-Fan     ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü 0
Huang, Shiou-Chuan     ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü 0
Lai, Fei-Pei ü   ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü ü 0

Note: For any director or supervisor who fulfills the relevant condition(s) for two fiscal years before being elected to the office or during the term of office,
please provide the [ü] sign in the field next to the corresponding conditions.
(1) Is not an employee of the Company or its affiliates.
(2) Is not a director or supervisor of the Company or its affiliates (the same does not apply, however, in cases where the person is an independent director
      in accordance with of the Company who serves concurrently as an independent director of its parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same parent 
     company the laws of Taiwan or with the laws of the country of the parent company, subsidiary or subsidiary of the same parent company).
(3) Does not directly or indirectly own more than 1% of the Company’s outstanding shares, nor is one of the top ten non-institutional shareholders of the Company.
(4) Is not a spouse, relative within the second degree of kinship, or lineal relative within the third degree of kinship of managers specified in the column (1) or
      any person specified in the column(2) and (3).
(5) Is not a director, supervisor, or employee of a legal entity that directly owns more than 5% of the Company’s issued shares or are the top five owners of
     the Company’s issued shares, nor a director, supervisor or employee of a legal entity which designates a representative to serve as a director or supervisor of
     the Company in accordance with Article 27, paragraph 1 or 2 of the Company Act (the same does not apply, however, in cases where the person is an
     independent director of the Company who serves concurrently as an independent director of its parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same parent
     company in accordance with the laws of Taiwan or with the laws of the country of the parent company, subsidiary or subsidiary of the same parent company).
(6) Is not a director, supervisor, or employee of other company, and more than half of directors or voting shares of other company are controlled by the same
     (the same does not apply, however, in cases where the person is an independent director of the Company who serves concurrently as a person Independent
     director of its parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same parent company in accordance with the laws of Taiwan or with the laws of the country
     of the parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same parent company).
(7) Is not a director, supervisor, or employee of other company, and Chairman, President or Manager with equivalent position of other company are the same
     person or spouse (the same does not apply, however, in cases where the person is an independent director of the Company who serves concurrently as an
     Independent director of its parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same parent company in accordance with the laws of Taiwan or with the laws of
      the country of the parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same parent company).
(8) Is not a director, supervisor, or manager of a company which has a business relationship with the Company, nor a shareholder who owns more than 5% of such
      a company (the same does not apply, however, in cases where a company owns more than 20% but less than 50% of the Company’s issued shares and the person
      is an independent director of the Company who serves concurrently as an independent director of its parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same
     parent company in accordance with the laws of Taiwan or with the laws of the country of the parent company, subsidiary, or subsidiary of the same parent company).
(9) Is not an owner, partner, director, supervisor, manager, or spouse of any sole proprietor business, partnership, company, or institution which has provided
      the Company and its affiliates with auditing or services of finance, business consult, and legal affairs for which the accumulated remuneration in the past
      two years does not exceed NTD 500,000, provided that this restriction does not apply to any member of the compensation committee, public  tender offer 
      review committee, or special committee on mergers and acquisitions exercises powers according to related regulations such as the
     “Securities and Exchange Act” or the “Business Mergers And Acquisitions Act.”
(10) Is not a spouse or relative within the second degree of kinship of any of the directors.
(11) Is not under any condition pursuant to Article 30 of the Company Act.
(12) Is not a legal entity owner or its representative pursuant to Article 27 of the Company Act.


Directors' expertise and independent directors' independence

                      Qualification
Name
Qualifications and Experience Independence Status Number of number Other Public Companies Where the Individual Concurrently Serves as an independent director
Pan, Yung-Chung He has worked as a senior manager and a director of the Company and has worked as a senior manager and a director of the Company and its subsidiaries for more than 33 years with the work experience required for this industry, marketing, management, and the Company's business. He has abilities in respects of decision-making, management, risk management, and information technology. There are no matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. Non-independent director None
Pan, Yung-Tai He has worked as a senior manager and a director of the Company and its has worked as a senior manager and a director of the Company and its subsidiaries for more than 35 years, with work experience in the industry, research and development, management, and the Company's business, and is well-qualified in decision-making, management, and information technology. There are no matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. None
Duh, Jia-Bin He has worked as a director, Chairman of Board, President, and Chief StrategyHe has worked as a director, Chairman of Board, President, and Chief StrategyOfficer of the Company and its subsidiaries for more than 30 years, with the work experience required for this industry, R&D, marketing, management, and the Company's business. He has abilities in respect of decision-making, management, risk management, information technology, and accounting. He was Chairman of Foxconn Technology Co., Ltd., Chairman of MobinnovaCo., Ltd., CEO of Cisco Systems, Inc., and Director of LAOWANG HOLDING LIMITED TAIWAN BRANCH (CAYMAN). There are no matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. None
Lee, Ji-Ren He has served as Vice Dean engaging in Teaching and Resource Development, He has served as Vice Dean engaging in Teaching and Resource Development, Vice Dean of the School of Management, and Executive Director of the EMBA program at National Taiwan University. He is now a professor emeritus at the University of Taiwan. He is specialized in strategic management and planning of enterprises. He won the National Golden Book Award in 2014 and 2015 and has helped enterprises establish medium- and long-term growth strategies, develop organizational capabilities and leadership talents, and promote the transformation of enterprises. He has served as Manager of the Marketing Service Department of Boehringer Ingelheim Taiwan Ltd., Chairman of Cheng Zhi Education Foundation, representative and Director of AXR Entrepreneurship and Business ConsultingCo., Ltd., Chairman of B Current Impact Investment Fund3, Director of SocialEnterprise Insights Co., Ltd., Independent Director of Delta ElectronicsInc., Director of Commonwealth Education Media and Publishing Co., Ltd., Legal representative and director of Longchen Paper & Packaging Co., Ltd., Director of Commonwealth Education Media and Publishing Co., Ltd., Director of Commonwealth Magazine Co., Ltd., Independent Director of AirohaTechnology Corp., and Director of Advantech Co., Ltd.There are not the matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. 1
Wu, Chun-Pang He has over 35 years of relevant working experience in marketing, finance, He has over 35 years of relevant working experience in marketing, finance, management, and banking, and has a Bachelor of Law degree from NationalTaiwan University with legal expertise and relevant skills in leadership, decisionmaking, business management, risk management, and financial accounting, and can enhance the supervision function of the Board of Directors and functional committees. He was the General Manager of Deutsche Bank Taipei, Vice Chairman of Citibank, Head of Fidelity Investments Taiwan, Head and Managing Director of Bankers Trust New York Corporation, Vice General Manager of Chase Bank, and Representative of Institutional Director of Far Eastern International Bank. There are no matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. The five independent directors listed herein, during the two years before their appointment and throughout their tenure, all meet the qualification requirements set forth by the Financial Supervisory Commission's "Regulations Governing Appointment of Independent Directors and Compliance Matters for Public Companies" and Article 14-2 of the Securities and Exchange Act. Furthermore, these independent directors have been granted the right to fully participate in decision-making and express their opinions in accordance with Article 14-3 of the Securities and Exchange Act, thereby executing their relevant duties independently.  None
Wang, Jia-Chyi She has more than 30 years of work experience in finance, risk, financialShe has more than 30 years of work experience in finance, risk, financial accounting, and management, and a good command of decision-making, management, risk management, and financial accounting. She can contribute to the quality of the board of directors and the supervision of its committees. She served as a mentor of the direct investment department of Ping An Trust of China, a global senior partner of Egon Zehnder International and general manager of its consumer electronics industry department, an associate of the corporate development department of Primax Electronics Ltd., a consultant of McKinsey (Hong Kong/Shanghai), a project manager of P&G Taiwan, managing director of Zenith Consulting Company Limited, and an operating partner of CITIC Capital Holdings Limited. There are no matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. None
Ma, Hui-Fan She has more than 30 years of work experience in Information Technology, She has more than 30 years of work experience in information technology, risk, and management, and good command of decision-making, management, risk management, and information technology. She can contribute to the quality of the board of directors and the supervision of its committees. She was Human Resources Director of NCR Corporation Greater China area, Human Resources Director of PE Bio Systems Asia Pacific area, Vice General Manager of the Human Resources Department at PRIMAX, Senior Vice President of Human Resources at Trend Micro Inc., Manager of Human Resources for TSMC, and Vice President of Human Resources at TSMC. There are no matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. None
Huang, Shiou-Chuan He has served as the vice president and vice chairman of many multinational companies such as HP Taiwan Information Technology Ltd., Hon Hai Precision Industry Co., Ltd., and Innolux. Corporation He participated in many company growth plans and was committed to electronics-related industries. He is currently the chairman of VIZIONFOCUS INC. He has rich corporate governance, marketing, industry knowledge, leadership and decision-making capabilities and operation and management experience. He can contribute to the quality of the board of directors and the supervision of its committees.There are no matters specified in Article 30 of the Companies Act. None
Lai, Fei-Pei He is a professor at the Department of Computer Science & Information Engineering and Department of Electrical Engineering, NTU. He has the experience required for corporate business. He has served as the chairman of the Institute of Information & Computing Machinery, and the Chairman of the Taiwan Information Technology Development Education Foundation. Independent director of HannStar Display Corporation. He can contribute to the quality of the board of directors and the supervision of its committees. There are no circumstances under Article 30 of the Company Law. None

 


Continuing education of directors

To improve the performance of board members, training courses are arranged by the Company in accordance with "Primax Electronics Corporate Governance Principles", "Directions for the Implementation of Continuing Education for Directors and Supervisors of TWSE Listed and TPEx Listed Companies", and other relevant regulations on the latest domestic and overseas developments in economic, environmental and social governance. Topics included finance, risk management, business, commerce, accounting, law, corporate governance, integrity, ethics, and corporate social responsibility. These training courses help board members maintain their values, professionalism and capabilities. The nine Primax directors attended 66 hours of continuing in education during 2023 and complied with the requirements set by“Directions for the Implementation of Continuing Education for Directors and Supervisors of TWSE Listed and TPEx Listed Companies.”Re-elected directors were required to complete at least 6 hours of training during their term, while newly-elected directors were required to complete at least 12 hours. Please refer to the table below for further details on the continuing education of directors during 2023.

 

Title
Name
Date of 
Appointment
Date of 
Initial Appointment
Date of Class
Conducting Entity 
Name of the Class
Course 
Duration
Total Training 
Hours
for the Year
Director
Duh, Jia-Bin
2021/7/13
2021/7/13
2023/6/2
Chinese National Association of Industry and
Commerce, Taiwan (CNAIC) 
2023 Taishin Net Zero Summit
3
6
2023/9/4
Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC)
The 14th Taipei Corporate Governance Forum (Morning Session)
3
Director
Pan, Yung-Tai
2021/7/13
2014/09/05
2023/12/13
Greater China Financial and Economic
DevelopmentAssociation
Corporate Circular Economy and Sustainability
3
6
2023/12/21
Taiwan Project Management 
Association
ESG Investing and Corporate SocialESG Investing and
Corporate SocialResponsibility
3
Director
Pan, Yung-Chung
2021/7/13
2014/09/05
2023/10/13
Securities and Future Institute 
2023 Insider Trading Prevention Seminar
3
6
2023/11/22
Taiwan Project Management 
Association
ESG Investing and Corporate SocialESG Investing and
Corporate SocialResponsibility
3
Director
Green LandGreen Land 
Investment Limited
Representative:
Lee, Ji-Ren
2021/7/13
2004/8/26
2023/3/16
Taiwan Corporate Governance Association 
World Economic Outlook for 2023
1.5
2023/5/4
Taiwan Corporate Governance Association 
Global Future Risks and Opportunities for Global Future Risks and
Opportunities for Sustainable Transformation 2023
1.5
2023/7/31
Taiwan Corporate Governance Association 
AI Technologies, Applications and AI Technologies, 
Applications andSocioeconomic Impact
3
2023/12/5
Taiwan Institute of Directors
Generative AI Leading Industry and BusinessGenerative
AI Leading Industry and Business Transformation
3
Independent 
Director
Cheng, Chih-Kai
2021/7/13
2015/06/29
2023/4/11
Securities and Future Institute 
Global Economy and Industry TechnologyGlobal Economy and
Industry TechnologyDevelopment Trends
3
2023/5/30
Taiwan Corporate Governance Association 
The Emerging Risk: Climate Change
3
Independent 
Director
Wu, Chun-Pang
2021/7/13
2017/06/15
2023/3/28
Securities and Future Institute 
How to Supervise the Company to Establish andHow to 
Supervise the Company to Establish and promote Comprehensive
Risk Management for the Board
3
2023/3/30
Securities and Future Institute 
Economy and Industry Trends 2023
3
Independent 
Director
Wang, Jia-Chyi 
2021/7/13
2019/06/18
2023/2/14
Taiwan Corporate Governance Association
New Challenge to Corporate Governance as
New Challenge to Corporate Governance asESG Knocking
3
2023/5/19
Greater China Financial and greater China 
Financial and Economic Development Association
ESG and Compliance
3
Independent 
Director
Shen, Ying-Chuan
2021/7/13
110/6/24
2023/5/24
Taiwan Institute of Directors
SAP NOW Taiwan Sustainable Practices: Leading to the Future
3
6
2023/9/4
Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC)
The 14th Taipei Corporate Governance Forum (Afternoon Session)
3
Independent 
Director
Ma, Hui-Fan
2021/7/13
112/5/23
2023/5/24
Taiwan Institute of Directors
SAP NOW Taiwan Sustainable Practices: Leading to the Future
3
15
2023/5/30
Securities and Futures Institute
(Independent) Director, Supervisor and(Independent) Director, 
Supervisor and corporate Governance Officer Practical Workshop
12

         

Directors' remuneration

A Compensation Committee has been created directly under the board of directors in accordance with the "Primax Electronics Compensation Committee Charter" to review remuneration policies, systems, standards, and structures, and to approve and evaluate performance targets for all directors, executives, and managers. None of the committee members have undertaken this role within concurrent Company service.

The remunerations of directors include rewards and compensations. The Company Articles of Association stipulate that should the Company make a profit, no more than 2% of it shall be used as rewards for the directors. This is subject to discussion by the Compensation Committee, resolution of the Board, as well as by presentation to a Meeting of the shareholders. Reasonable rewards are decided by reference to operation performance, contribution to such performance, and the outcome of appraisal by the Board. The Chairman’s remuneration is proposed by the HR Department after a consideration of the competitive environment, the operational risks on the basis of management regulations, and a bonus plan assessment. The Compensation Committee makes a proposal after an assessment of performance which is then submitted to the board for approval. The relevant appraisals and reasonableness of compensations are reviewed by the Compensation Committee and the Board. The remuneration system is subject to review based on the actual operation and relevant laws and regulations.

The Compensation Committee, which has been created directly under the board of directors in accordance with the "Primax Electronics Compensation Committee Charter", reviews the remuneration policies, systems, standards, and structures, and approves and evaluates performance targets for all directors, executives, and managers. None of the committee members have undertaken this role while concurrently serving with the company.

Directors' remuneration is paid according to the Company Articles of Incorporation. The remuneration of Executives and managers is a combination of fixed salary, a year-end bonus, and variable bonuses that are determined based on yearly performance results. Fixed salaries are set at a level deemed competitive within the industry, whereas variable bonuses are calculated at the beginning of each year based on a number of factors including the overall business environment, company growth, performance targets and weights, and how these targets are accomplished. These sums are reviewed by the Compensation Committee and are subject to approval by the board of directors. The Company may issue stock options, restricted shares or use other incentives of material effect to retain managers who exhibit long-term potential. These incentives are also reviewed by the Compensation Committee and are subject to approval by the board of directors.

Performance Evaluation for Board of Directors

The Board of Directors undergoes a performance evaluation each December in accordance with the Primax "Rules for Performance Evaluation of the Board of Directors." An external evaluation of Board performance must also be conducted once every three years. According to the aforementioned rules, the performance evaluation should cover the following areas at a minimum:

Subject Board of Directors Director members Functional committees
Required areas of assessment

1. Engagement in the operations of the Company.
2. Enhancement of the quality of decision-making of the BOD.
3. Composition and structure of the BOD.
4. The election and continuing education of the members of the BOD.
5. Internal control.

1. Grasping the goal of the company and mission.
2. Awareness of the duties of directors.
3. Engagement in the operations of the Company.
4. Internal relationship management and communications.
5. The election and continuing education of the directors. 
6. Internal control.

1. Engagement in the operations of the Company.
2. Awareness of the duties of a functional committee member.
3. Enhancement to the quality of functional committee decision-making.
4.  Composition of the functional committee and selection of committee members.
5. Internal control.

 

Outcome of the evaluation is rated using a 5-grade scale. Results of the evaluations are also reported to the BOD for review and improvement.

 Material Improvement Needed        Improvement Needed           Average            Good            Excellent     
1 2 3 4 5

 

Grade Description

Excellent  Consistent with better international governance practices.     
Good  Consistent with better domestic governance practices.
Average  Consistent with domestic regulations or general standards.
Improvement Needed  Inconsistent with domestic regulations or general standards to a minor extent    
  Material Improvement Needed     Severe deficiencies exist.

 

Performance evaluations are conducted by Primax for the entire Board, individual Board members, and functional committees (Audit and Compensation) in accordance with the aforementioned rules and scope of evaluation. Evaluations take the form of internal self-assessment by the Board, self-assessment by Board members, and performance evaluations conducted by external bodies, experts or other means as appropriate.

Internal performance evaluation for the 2020 Board of Directors was completed at the end of 2020 in accordance with the rules. The evaluation of the Finance and Administration Department was conducted in questionnaire format. Performance evaluations of the Board, the Board members, and of the Audit and Compensation Committees all produced outcomes ranging from Good to Excellent. The average scores given by directors for each questionnaire ranged from 4.96 (Agree) to 5 (Strongly agree). The Directors concluded that the Primax Board and its functional committees were working smoothly and effectively.

The most recent external evaluation of Board performance was conducted in 2020 by KPMG Taiwan which satisfies the criteria for an external evaluation institution as defined in Article 7 of the “Sample Template of "Self-Evaluation or Peer Evaluation of the Board of Directors of XX Co Ltd." Services provided by KPMG Taiwan include education and training courses for company boards, the improvement of corporate governance, risk management, internal controls and audits. The KPMG evaluation team has all the necessary independence and professionalism.

KPMG completed the assessment in December 2020, using domestic and international tools to carry out an evaluation of best practices. This took three forms: data analysis, questionnaires, and interviews. The areas assessed, including individual aspects, are listed below:

Subject Board of Directors Director members Audit Committee Compensation Committee
Measurement Area 9 Key Aspects and 89 Assessment Items 6 Key Aspects and 27 Assessment Items 6 Key Aspects and 89 Assessment Items 5 Key Aspects and 52 Assessment Items
Aspect Description

1. Establishing a functional board of directors
2. Effective operation of the Board.
3. Professional development and continuing education.

4. Vision of the company.

5. Fulfillment of duties.

6. Supervision of management.
7. The shaping of corporate culture.
8. Communications with stakeholders.
9.
Performance evaluation.

1. Grasp of Company goals and missions.
2. Understanding directors' duties and responsibilities.
3. Professional development and continuing education.

4. Fulfillment of duties.

5. Engagement with Company operations.
6. Internal relationship management and communications.
1.Establishing a functional Audit Committee.
2. Effective operation of the Audit Committee

3. Fulfillment of duties.

4. The establishment of a whistle-blower mechanism.

5. Relationship with the Board
6. Performance evaluation
1. Establishing functional Compensation Committee.
2. Effective operation of the Compensation Committee.
3. Fulfillment of duties.

4. Relationship with the Board

5. Performance evaluation.

 

The outcome of the 2020 external evaluation of general Board performance:

Polices and processes have been put into place for the Board as a whole and for individual directors in accordance with the relevant laws and domestic corporate governance indicators. Board directors possess the relevant qualifications and ability, and there is appropriate division of labor to ensure the effective function of the Board and functional committees (Audit and Compensation Committees). Overall performance was found to range from Good to Excellent.

Recommendations and future improvements derived from the 2020 external performance evaluation of the Primax Board of Directors:

Subject Board and individual directors Audit Committee Compensation Committee
Recommendation 1. Better overseas practices should be added to the Board meetings agendas. Annual work plans and tasks should be developed to aid effective tracking and better exercise of responsibilities.
2. Consider referring ISO and COSO publications on corporate risk management and a sustainable development roadmap for corporate governance 3.0. 1. Better overseas practices should go on the agenda for Board meetings. Annual work plans and tasks should be developed to aid in the effective tracking and exercise of responsibilities.
To ensure greater diligence by the Company on the functioning of the Audit Committee, annual work plans and tasks should be developed for   effective tracking and the exercise of responsibilities. The Company should set annual tasks for the Compensation Committee along with regular reviews. Annual work plans should be developed to aid  effective tracking and the exercise of responsibilities.
Improvement plan 1. The Company plans to improve execution by including regular agendas to the annual work plan.
2. A corporate risk assessment report was presented to the Board in July, 2020. All potential risks relating to strategies, operations, finance and harmful climate change will be consolidated and managed in a proactive, cost-effective manner in the future. This will ensure appropriate risk management for all stakeholders.
The Company plans to improve execution by including regular agendas in the annual work plan. The Company plans to improve execution by including regular agendas in the annual work plan.

The general outcome of all the internal and external performance evaluations were reported to the Board on January 22, 2021. Please refer to the 2020 Annual Report for further details.

The Company "Rules for Performance Evaluation of the Board of Directors"

The avoidance of conflicts of interest

The Company has implemented a "Corporate Governance Code of Conduct" and "Business Integrity Procedures and Behavioral Guidelines." These clearly state, that should a director, manager, board meeting participant, or any of the corporate entities represented by them, be a stakeholder in a matter under discussion at a board meeting, the party must make this fact known to the meeting, disclose the stakes involved, and shall disassociate themselves from all discussions and voting in conflict with the interests of the company. Furthermore, the concerned party may not exercise proxy voting rights on behalf of any other directors. All Company directors are highly disciplined in their conduct and have always managed to disassociate themselves from agendas that present conflicts of interest. For more disclosures regarding avoidance of such conflict by the highest governance body, please refer to the corporate governance chapter on "Page 24 of the 2023 Annual General Meeting Report."